Common clinical experience suggests that tooth whitening agents are 100% effective. This study uses meta-analysis of data from published randomized controlled clinical trials to determine the efficacy of tooth whitening agents.
Methods
A MEDLINE search strategy was developed and implemented to systematically identify clinical trials on dentist-prescribed, home-applied tooth whitening agents, using 10% carbamide peroxide, published between 1989-1999. Inclusion criteria (e.g., in English, human clinical trials) and exclusion criteria (e.g., not placebo controlled) were established and clinical trials that met these criteria were critically appraised for validity and clinical applicability. Meta-analysis was then used to quantitatively integrate the findings.
Results
Seven studies were identified that met the inclusion and validity criteria. These studies indicated that:
Whitening results in a significant mean change of 6 4 shade guide units (p < 0.01), while the placebo control group exhibited little change (0.7 0.6, p > 0.05).
93% of the bleached patients exhibited 2 shade guide unit change, while 20% of the placebo control group exhibited this change.
The brand of bleaching agent had a significant effect on tooth whitening, but the daily application time and duration of treatment did not.
Whitening is maintained for 6 months for 1/2 of the people treated.
Neither gingival indices nor plaque indices were adversely or favorably affected by bleaching.
Clinical Applicability
The data from the reviewed studies indicate that rather than being 100% effective, on average:
73% (93% for bleached group minus 20% placebo group) of people who whiten their teeth will exhibit a whitening that is 2 shade guide units greater than the placebo.
20% of the people who use dentist-prescribed, home-applied bleaching will achieve a mean whitening effect of 5 shade guide units.
Re-treatment for 50% of people may be necessary to maintain this effect longer than 6 months.
The methods used here are Internet applicable for other clinical topics.
Nightguard vital bleaching. Quintessence Int 1989;20(3):173-6.
Effectiveness, side effects, and long-term status of nightguard vital bleaching. J Am Dent Assoc 1994;125:1219-1226.
Evaluating tooth color change from carbamide peroxide gel. J Am Dent Assoc 1993;134:65-72.
Pulpal response to vital bleaching procedures. J Endod 1980;6:645-9.
Human pulpal response to bleaching procedures on vital teeth. J Endod 1979;5:134-8.
Guidelines for the acceptance of peroxide-containing oral hygiene products. J Am Dent Assoc 1994;125:1140-1142.
An evidence-based treatment approach: Translating clinical outcomes to patient value. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent 1998;3:327-38.
Evidence-based medicine. How to practice and teach EBM. New York: Churchill Libingsone, 1997.
Post-operative bleaching: effect on microleakage. Am J Dent 1992;5(2):109-12.
Sealing ability of two intermediate restorative materials in bleached teeth. Am J Dent 1992;5(3):141-4.
The effect of carbamide peroxide bleach on the tensile bond strength of ceramic brackets: an in vitro study. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 1994;106(4):371-5.
, Bayne SC, May KN Jr., Wilder AD Jr., Mann GB, Peterson CA. Clinical evaluation of two carbamide peroxide tooth-whitening agents. Compend Contin Educ Dent 1998;19(4):359-62, 364-6, 369.
Comparative clinical evaluation of two professional tooth-whitening products. Compendium 1994;Suppl 17:S635-9.
Clinical evaluation of Colgate Platinum Professional Toothwhitening System and Rembrandt Lighten Bleaching Gel. Compendium 1994; Suppl 17: S640-5.
Clinical changes in the gingiva as a result of at-home bleaching. Compendium 1993;14(11)1362,1364-6.
The effects of bleaching application time on the dental pulp. J Am Dent Assoc 1994;125(10):1330-5.
al. In vivo degradation of bleaching gel used in whitening teeth. J Am Dent Assoc 1999 Feb;130(2):227-35.
The laboratory and clinical safety evaluation of a dentrifice containing hydrogen peroxide and baking soda. J Clin Dent. 1992;3(4):104-10.
Clinical efficacy of a degradable film-forming product containing carbamide peroxide to reduce tooth discolouration. Oral Health 1996;86(3):47-9.
Effective tooth bleaching in 5 days: using a combined inoffice and at-home bleaching system. Compend Contin Educ Dent 1997;18(4):378,380-3.
A clinical comparison of two bleaching systems. J Calif Dent Assoc. 1995;23(12):59-64.
The efficacy and safety of a 10% carbamide peroxide bleaching gel. Quintessence Int 1998;29(9):555-63.
Randomized clinical trial of the efficacy and safety of a home bleaching procedure. Quintessence Int 1996;27(6):413-24.
, Downey MC, Haywood VB, Myers ML. Dentist-supervised home bleaching with ten percent carbamide peroxide gel: a six-month study. J Esthet Dent 1996;8(4):177-82.
Clinical comparison of Colgate Platinum Toothwhitening System and Rembrandt Gel Plus. Compendium 1994; Suppl 17: S646-51.
, Denehy GE. A clinical study of nightguard vital bleaching. Quintessence Int 1993; 24(6): 379-84.
Patient-applied tooth whiteners. J Am Dent Assoc 1992;123(2):57-60.
Assessing the effects of 10 percent carbamide peroxide on oral soft tissues. J Am Dent Assoc 1995;127(8):1218-23.
Meta-Analysis: Potentials and promise. BMJ 1997:315:1371-4.
Papers that summarize other papers (systematic reviews and meta-analyses) BMJ 1997;315:672-5.
Problems in the “evidence” of “evidence-based medicine.” Am J Med 1997;103:529-35.
Discrepancies between meta-analysis and subsequent large randomized controlled trials. New Engl J Med 1997;337:536-42. Christensen GL. Bleaching Teeth: Report of a Survey, 1997. J Esth Dent 1998; 10 (1): 16–20.
